Phonics vs. Whole Word Reading for Dyslexic Children: What’s Best and Why?

When it comes to teaching children with dyslexia how to read, two primary approaches often come into the spotlight: phonics and whole word reading. Each has its benefits, but which one is best for dyslexic learners? And when should a strategy be changed if it’s not working?

Understanding Phonics and Whole Word Reading

Phonics is a method that teaches children to decode words by sounding out letters and letter combinations. It emphasizes the relationship between letters (graphemes) and sounds (phonemes). Phonics instruction builds from the smallest units of sound to more complex word patterns, helping children sound out unfamiliar words.

Whole word reading, on the other hand, focuses on recognizing entire words by sight rather than decoding them. This method encourages children to memorize word shapes, using the whole word as a unit. Over time, children with this approach are expected to automatically recognize the words without sounding them out.

For children with dyslexia, both approaches have their merits, but research suggests that one tends to be more effective than the other in the long term.

Why Phonics Works Best for Dyslexic Children

Dyslexia is a neurological condition that affects the brain’s ability to process written language. Individuals with dyslexia often struggle with decoding words, recognizing letter-sound relationships, and sounding out unfamiliar words. As a result, reading can be incredibly challenging for them. This is where phonics shines.

1. Breaking Down Words into Manageable Parts: Phonics helps dyslexic children by breaking words down into smaller, more manageable chunks. It teaches them to recognize letter patterns and sounds, which aids in decoding new words. For children with dyslexia, this structured approach offers clear steps to follow, reducing the cognitive overload that can come with trying to recognize entire words at once.
2. Improving Decoding Skills: Phonics helps dyslexic children gain confidence in their ability to decode words. When they learn how to use letter-sound correspondence, they can apply this skill to any word, not just those they’ve memorized. This adaptability is especially important for dyslexic readers who may struggle with the irregularities and complexities of English spelling.
3. Targeting the Core Issue: Dyslexia primarily affects the brain’s ability to process sounds and letters. Phonics directly targets this issue by reinforcing sound-letter relationships, allowing dyslexic children to overcome one of their primary challenges.
4. Long-Term Benefits: Phonics instruction has been shown to result in significant long-term improvements in reading and spelling skills for children with dyslexia. Studies indicate that children who receive explicit phonics instruction are more likely to become fluent readers than those who rely on memorizing whole words.

The Role of Whole Word Reading

While phonics is highly effective for many dyslexic children, whole word reading can still have a place in a comprehensive literacy program. Here’s how whole word reading may be beneficial:

1. Familiarity with Sight Words: Some words in English don’t follow regular phonetic rules and can be challenging to decode using phonics (e.g., “is,” “was,” “though”). Whole word reading is helpful for teaching these sight words—words that children need to recognize by memory because they don’t fit into phonetic patterns.
2. Encouraging Fluency: Once a child has learned to decode words through phonics, they can begin to rely on whole word recognition for faster reading. This can boost fluency and help children read more smoothly without having to stop and decode every single word.
3. Confidence and Motivation: For some children with dyslexia, seeing their progress in recognizing whole words can boost confidence and motivation. If they can quickly recognize a few words, they may feel more inclined to continue practicing and engaging with texts.

When Should You Change Strategies?

While phonics generally provides the best foundation for dyslexic children, there are situations where switching or combining strategies may be beneficial. Here are some scenarios to consider:

1. When Phonics Is Not Working: If a child has been receiving phonics instruction for an extended period (e.g., several months) without making progress, it might be time to re-evaluate the approach. Some children may need more intensive or specialized instruction. For example, multisensory approaches like the Orton-Gillinghammethod combine phonics with tactile, visual, and auditory learning to help reinforce connections.
2. When Fluency Needs a Boost: After a solid foundation in phonics has been laid, whole word reading might be helpful for increasing reading fluency. This can be especially important if the child is still slow or hesitant in their reading, despite understanding phonics rules.
3. If Motivation Is Lagging: Sometimes, children with dyslexia become frustrated with the slow progress that phonics instruction can sometimes bring. Introducing whole word reading can provide them with a sense of accomplishment, as they’ll be able to quickly recognize familiar words and engage with books at a more fluent level. This may rekindle their enthusiasm for reading and learning.
4. When Teaching Complex Words: Some words have irregular spellings that make them difficult to decode using phonics alone. In these cases, whole word recognition can be helpful, but it should be paired with phonics instruction to ensure that the child can still learn strategies for dealing with unfamiliar words in the future.

The Bottom Line: Phonics as the Core, Whole Word as the Supplement

In most cases, phonics should be the core strategy for teaching dyslexic children to read. Phonics instruction directly addresses the primary challenges dyslexic children face by providing them with the tools they need to decode words. Over time, as the child’s decoding skills improve, they can also begin incorporating whole word recognition to enhance fluency and word recall.

Ultimately, teaching reading to a child with dyslexia is not about using one strategy in isolation but finding the right balance between approaches that meet the child’s unique needs. Regular monitoring of progress, reassessment of strategies, and flexibility in approach will ensure that each child is supported in the most effective way possible.

Dyslexic children can become confident, capable readers, but it requires time, patience, and the right tools. By emphasising phonics while integrating whole word recognition as needed, we can help children with dyslexia unlock the world of reading.

K x